Can nearly 300 protests force out India's election chief?
She was far from alone. In the 10 days to October 2, Indians protested the Election Commission 278 times in 26 of the country's 28 states. That is about 23 times the usual pace, according to an India Today analysis of data from the non-profit Armed Conflict Location and Event Data.
And the biggest test may be days away. On Saturday, October 10, student unions and the Cockroach Janta Party, the youth movement whose protests forced out the education minister in July, plan a joint protest in Delhi, according to ACLED.
At stake are Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar's job and the trust voters place in the body that runs India's elections. Protesters want him to resign over the Special Intensive Revision, a nationwide re-check of the voter list. Opposition parties allege it has wiped eligible voters off the rolls. The commission says it removes duplicate and ineligible entries.
Many of the protests followed an investigation. Two of the three election commissioners objected on record at least 14 times in 10 months to decisions taken under Kumar, including adding and deleting voters, it found.
The commission said "differing views" were part of its decision-making and that its decisions were unanimous. On October 5, the Supreme Court declined to suspend Kumar and asked the commission and the government to answer the petitions against him.ONE MONDAY, TWO IN THREE PROTESTS
Two in every three came on a single day, Monday, September 28, when ACLED recorded 187. Congress or one of its wings took part in all but one. Three days earlier, on Friday, September 25, opposition parties held nationwide protests.
They spread from Jammu and Kashmir to Puducherry. Among states, only Rajasthan and Sikkim recorded none, and Rajasthan's gap is partly a quirk of record-keeping: a Congress march in Jaipur on September 28, over what the party called "vote theft", was logged as a march to the state's chief electoral officer, without naming the commission.PEACEFUL, EXCEPT DELHI
More than nine in 10 protests passed off peacefully, the data shows.
The capital was different. Police stepped in at half of Delhi's protests, dispersing, detaining or otherwise stopping them, according to the data. Delhi Police “have forcibly broken up several peaceful protests,” Pearl Pandya, ACLED's South Asia analyst, wrote. The Leader of the Opposition, Rahul Gandhi, was detained on two days running.
This is, above all, as the data suggests, an opposition campaign. Congress or its affiliates took part in more than eight in 10 protests. The Cockroach Janta Party, which filled the streets in July, appears in only two so far.
"The election commission is a puppet in the hands of the government," Mallikarjun Kharge, the Congress president, said on October 6. The Bharatiya Janata Party sees it differently. "After failing multiple times, Congress leaders have decided to establish anarchy in the country and attack institutions," its spokesperson, Sambit Patra, said the same day.BIG, BUT NOT YET JULY
ACLED put the count at "nearly 300 protests" in 10 days on October 7 and called it nearly half of the previous 1.5 years’ count. Based on data released so far, which runs to October 2, India Today's count comes to about two-fifths.
Set against July, this wave is smaller. The protests over exam-paper leaks that forced out Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan came at twice the daily pace in their last 10 days. July's count covers protests the Cockroach Janta Party led.
On October 6, it said it had turned down a meeting with 240 MPs at Parliament House Annexe as "unusual," because such meetings are held at its own office. It offered to send its senior-most officer to take their memorandum instead, it said; the MPs declined.
Methodology: DIU analysed protests in India recorded by ACLED from September 23 to October 2, the latest data available. We count a protest if ACLED's description mentions the Election Commission, its chief, or the voter-list revision; this may miss at least one march. The usual pace is the daily average over the previous 18 months. Counts by state show how far the protests spread, not how intense they were.- Ends
Dipu Rai is an investigative and data journalist based in New Delhi focusing on data-driven stories on finance, health, politics and environment. He is also actively involved in analyses and visualisations of data at India Today's Data Intelligence Unit (DIU).
Dipu is well-versed in SQL, Python, R, Tableau and produces prototype visualisations quickly as per requirement. He is specialised in dealing with a variety of datasets with parsing, scraping and cleaning. Doing Spatial analysis is his hobby, and he frequently uses location intelligence platforms like Carto and QGIS.
After completing the master in economics, Dipu has started his career as a business journalist. He has more than ten years of experience in broadcast, print and digital platforms.
Dipu's work has sparked several financial investigations and won some of journalism's highest honours. He was awarded the Redink Award, in 2015 for financial crime reporting. He has translated Raymond Williams's book 'Television' in Hindi. His hobbies include reading codes, learning new visualisation techniques. In his spare time he likes to read books, listen to music and watch films.
Original Source
This content was distilled for a focused reading experience. All rights belong to India Today.
Read original publication